Skip to main content

That grey area

We are a part of the Masorti community here in Yokneam. Having grown up in Reform communities, engaged with Conservative and Orthodox programs and communities during our early adult years (which I hope we're still technically in!), we've been exposed to a great variety of ways to observe Judaism. We were raised by parents and in communities where religious observance is a journey of our lifetimes that ebbs and flows as our life unfolds.

That's not really how Israelis see religion which leads to this diametrical opposition of Religious (aka - Orthodox) and Secular camps with a huge gaping hole in the middle. It's no man's land. Apparently it's extremely dangerous is an unknown kind of way to step foot there. If you are Religious and consider doing something Secular it's the end of time, and if you are Secular and consider doing something Religious, yep, end of time! Well that's a gross simplification because there are certainly people who move between groups. But that isn't always easy, nor welcomed by family and friends.

For example, I mentioned to my two lovely neighbors at various times that the Yokneam Masorti (Ohel Menashe) community was having a Friday night Kabbalat Shabbat service and maybe they would like to come. It seemed like perhaps I was a religious solicitor ringing their doorbells and I imagine that the look on my face when I've had such folks at my door is how they were looking at me! And they each said something like: well that's super nice but I don't get it and it's probably not for me and probably wouldn't go over well with my husband. Or they pointed out in confusion they didn't get why it would be important, even beneficial for a husband and wife to sit together as a family for services. So the answer was thanks, but no thanks.

I have no problem being turned down when I ask for or offer something. I do get puzzled when the rejection comes from a place of total lack of understanding and disinterest in even considering something new and different. Life is too short to pass on opportunities that may enhance our lives. Which is not to say that you need to run out there and buy that new gadget you saw on TV at 3am that you can get for three easy payments of $24.95 plus bonus products galore!

So I found myself in a conversation with one of my kids today about why it is important to me that we go to and participate in the Masorti community here. And he came to understand this paradigm of two polar opposites with space in the middle - he made the analogy of two magnets of the same poles versus two of different poles overcoming the gap to be together. I explained to him that we have to provide another option in the middle to show both sides that there are more choices out there, more ways to be Jewish and more ways to pray as a Jew. And he got it! Now, that doesn't mean he'll be thrilled when it's time to walk over for services this week, but I do think he understands a bit better.

How then to help others see that filling in the empty space between Religious and Secular is not a threat, but rather a strengthening of Judaism as a whole?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Macher or Schmoozer?

I'm working my way slowly through the book Bowling Alone by Robert Putnam . In a nutshell, which has to be pretty big because it's a hefty book, it's about social behaviors and the decline of them in the US - things like voting and participating in the political process at all levels, and engaging with volunteer and community efforts. Chapter six looks at Informal Social Connections. At paragraph two of the chapter he mentions the Yiddish words macher and schmoozer . That stopped me in my tracks for a moment. He continued to explain that fundamentally a macher is a doer, someone who makes things happen in the community. Whereas a schmoozer is a talker, a person with an active social life, someone who focuses on informal connections to others. And while it is certainly nice to sit and talk with someone, at the end of the day that's all a schmoozer does. Alternatively, the macher will sit and visit with you and then either your roped into helping or the macher...

Women...Prayer...Finding Your Place

I grew up in a Reform community. It was the only Jewish community that served not only my city but also the larger county and even parts of the neighboring country. When I was in college, after visits to Israel, I found myself increasing the amount of religious observance in my life. Having been a vegetarian for many years, kashruth was not a concern. Fundamentally I was keeping kosher. Observing Shabbat, marking the end of each week was a new experience for me. That meant both participating more fully in Hillel activities for Friday night and also making my room a Shabbat observance space - walking places, not turning lights on and off, no computer, no phone. It was a good opportunity to recharge during the hectic atmosphere of college. After college I found myself participating in a large, Conservative synagogue and thoroughly finding my place, feeling that what I needed from Judaism, what I needed from prayer was being met. Then I got married (in a Conservative synagogue by a ...

Family...oy, family

We all come from a family, whether we belong to a family or not at the moment. By family, I mean there are people with whom you are closely, genetically related. I'm tackling a new project this week that involves making a number of phone calls. It's been fun and rewarding so far. Interestingly tonight as I made a few of the phone calls I was struck by some family connected-ness that I encountered. One call was to an old, dear friend. Our lives seem to keep crossing paths in a fairly informal kind of way - enough to keep our friendship alive but not necessarily deepen it or harm it, either. After some time living in other parts of the US she moved back to where she grew up and has sunk down deep roots. I was struck as we finished our chat about how nice that must be for her to be in a place so close to her family. Her family bonds remain strong so when a major family event happens they all gather, even if they all aren't in the same town. It's remarkable, really. A...